Is the United States Headed Towards Socialism?
I plan to add an in-depth column to bloviators.net in the next few days in which I will discuss our government’s many moves towards a socialist society. Until that time, and because I am honestly tired of bloviating about the financial crisis, I wanted to touch on a few points related to our steady march towards a government controlled socialist society.
I fear that most Americans are unaware of the socialistic storm that has been raging all around us for some time now. This is not to say Americans are not paying attention – in fact I think the contrary is true. It is easy to see major governmental changes when they come as a part of rapid reform, takeover, war, and many other methods. The recent and rapid nationalization of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae make good examples (yes, I promised not to talk about the financial thing). Setting aside some of the more recent moves the government has made into the private sector, though, one can still find an alarming number of areas where the federal government has been making gradual moves towards takeover.
Is National Healthcare Worth the Cost?
It is easy to lose one’s way in today’s political environment, which has largely become a world driven by polls and the whims of public opinion rather than what is really best for the country. An excellent example of socialistic policies enjoying a large amount of popular support are proposals to nationalize the healthcare system in the US. On the surface it sounds great – we all care about of fellow Americans and want them to have the best medical care possible – so what’s the problem, right?
The idea of a national healthcare program is not a new one. Several countries, and even some states within the US, have already put plans like this in place. The programs are marketed in such a way that they make the people who “have” feel guilty that others “have not.” The only problem is that healthcare is not a right – it is a privilege. It is a privilege no different than the privilege we have to drive a car, yet you don’t see the government stepping in to buy everyone in the country a car, nor do you, or should you, feel guilty when you drive past a bus stop and see people waiting for the bus. If you want to stop and give someone a ride you are free to do so, but don’t make everyone else on the road stop and pick someone up too.
Healthcare is no different. Sure, giving someone a ride is a little different than providing medical care, but the principal is the same. If you feel guilty that someone cannot afford healthcare do something about it. Volunteer your time at the hospital or a local clinic. Donate to any number of charities devoted to helping those in need. Go to your local nursing home and read to the residents. The beauty of America is that you are free do do whatever you want. The opportune word here is “you.” ”You” are free to do whatever “you” want. The problem is when you start letting your guilt affect the rest of our lives. Your freedom ends when you try to compel the rest of us to help alleviate your guilt.
I will go into more detail about how nationalized…more accurately socialized…healthcare will affect you in my column in the coming days, and I am willing to bet you might not realize the extreme costs associated with such a plan. I am not just referring to the financial burdens these programs will place on the taxpayer, although that is a big part of it, but also the overall levels of decreased (yes, decreased) care we will all receive as a result.
Welfare Programs and the True Unemployment Rate
The Bloviator believes that a major driving factor in the socialization of America is the collective guilt those who we will call “the haves” feel towards those we’ll term the “have nots.” However, another equally strong driving factor is our government official’s need to be in control. Since the dawn of time some people have needed to feel they are in a position of power above the rest of us. In the cave man days it was the tribal chieftains. In Egyptian times it was the Pharos. The Romans had senators and an emperor, the early church installed the Pope and the clergy, countless countries had (and many still have) kings and royal bloodlines, and all the way through the present every society has leadership of some kind that make the rules for the rest of us.
In the United States our founding fathers did their best to construct the basis for our society, the Constitution, in such a manner that our government would be by the people and for the people. Remember that many of our founding fathers were driven out of other oppressive regimes at the time, and that our country was born out of our disdain for the unfair control and taxation of King George and the English crown.
It is because of this that it is all the more sad that it has only taken us a little more than 225 years to pervert the visions of our founding fathers and circumvent the very checks and balances they created to prevent just such actions.
As with all prior governments, our current elected leadership has become drunk with power. They need this power; they need to be in control. For them to keep that power they need for us to depend on them. What better way to get the people dependent on the government than to create a welfare state? If you happen to be on the receiving end of the “government cheese” are you going to vote for a different party, or are you going to cast your vote for those who keep the welfare flowing? Even The Bloviator would be tempted by a free ride, so I understand how we are getting to this point even while I fight against it.
At last count, the national unemployment rate was 6.1%. By historical averages that is not such a bad rate. However, you need to understand that the 6.1% figure only accounts for people who want to work but cannot find a job. In the year 2000, nearly 12% of the American population were living below the poverty line (at the time, that meant they were making a household income of less than $18,000 per year). Factor in the elderly receiving Medicare benefits, more poor families receiving Medicaid benefits, and the elderly receiving social security benefits, and you have a substantial segment of the American public receiving government assistance of some sort.
We only talk about the unemployment rate, however it is much more sobering to talk about the overall dependency rate, which is many times higher, all funded at the taxpayers expense. With all those programs for so many segments of the population it is inevitable that we will eventually reach a tipping point whereby the majority of the population is dependent on the government in one way or another, at which time there is no turning back.
It will be at that point that we are truly a socialist country. Federal income tax data from 2001 shows that the top 5% of income earners paid 53% of all federal income taxes. The top 10% of all income earners paid nearly 65% of all federal income taxes, and the top 50% (that’s half the population of income earners) paid 96% of all federal income taxes.
With the top 50% of income earning Americans paying 96% of all income taxes The Bloviator fears we may have already crossed that point of no return. How much more of this can our society take?